Past modals: should have, could have, must have

Talk about past regrets, missed chances and guesses: "I should have called", "She must have forgotten".

Lesson 32 Upper-intermediate · B2

In one sentence

Modal + have + past participle talks about the past: regrets and criticism (should have), missed possibilities (could have), and guesses (must / might / can't have).

Tip: I should have left earlier. = I didn't leave early, and that was a mistake.

The form

Structure Meaning Example
should(n't) have + p.p. regret / criticism You should have told me. I shouldn't have eaten so much.
could have + p.p. possible but didn't happen We could have won — we were so close!
must have + p.p. almost sure (past) The streets are wet. It must have rained.
might / may have + p.p. possible (past) She might have missed the bus.
can't / couldn't have + p.p. almost sure not (past) He can't have seen us — he didn't wave.

Short forms in speech: should've, could've, must've (never should of).

When to use it

  1. Regret about your own actions — I should have studied harder for the exam.
  2. Criticising someone — You shouldn't have shouted at him.
  3. Missed opportunities — You could have asked me for help!
  4. Deduction about the past — Mia isn't here. She must have gone home.
  5. Uncertain explanations — Leo is late. He may have got lost.

Examples with Leo & Mia

  • Leo: I failed the driving test again.
  • Mia: Oh no! What happened?
  • Leo: I was too nervous. I should have practised more on busy roads.
  • Mia: You could have asked me — I would have helped. And the examiner must have noticed you were nervous.

Common mistakes

  • ❌ I should of called you. → ✅ I should have called you. — "of" is a spelling mistake for 've.
  • ❌ You should have tell me. → ✅ You should have told me. — past participle.
  • ❌ She must have forget. → ✅ She must have forgotten.
  • ❌ He mustn't have seen us. (sure: no) → ✅ He can't have seen us.
  • ❌ I should study yesterday. → ✅ I should have studied yesterday.

Check yourself

Type or choose your answers, then check them.

  1. I failed the test. I ___ (study) harder. (regret)

  2. The ground is wet. It ___ during the night.

  3. Leo ___ the email — he replied to it an hour ago!

  4. Which sentence is correct?

  5. We ___ (win) the match — we only lost by one goal! (possible but didn't happen)

You'll need a free account to see your score and the answers.