Modals of deduction: must, might, can't

"She must be tired." "He might be at home." "That can't be true." Say how sure you are about the present.

Lesson 31 Intermediate · B1

In one sentence

Use must when you're almost sure something is true, might / may / could when it's possible, and can't when you're almost sure it's not true.

Tip: The opposite of must be (sure: yes) is can't be (sure: no) — not mustn't be.

The form

How sure? Modal + verb Example
~95% yes must + verb She's been working all day. She must be tired.
~50% might / may / could + verb He's not answering. He might be in a meeting.
~95% no can't + verb That can't be Leo — he's in Japan this week.
in progress now modal + be + -ing They must be having dinner.

When to use it

  1. Logical conclusion (positive) — The lights are on. Someone must be home.
  2. Possibility — Take an umbrella. It might rain later.
  3. Logical conclusion (negative) — You've just eaten! You can't be hungry already.
  4. Actions happening now — Listen! Mia must be practising the piano.
  5. Questions about possibility — Where's my wallet? Could it be in the car?

Examples with Leo & Mia

  • Mia: Whose bag is this?
  • Leo: It must be Nam's — it has his name on it.
  • Mia: He can't be far. His coffee is still hot.
  • Leo: He might be in the library. Let's check there.

Common mistakes

  • ❌ She mustn't be at home — her car is gone. → ✅ She can't be at home… — sure "no" → can't.
  • ❌ He must to be busy. → ✅ He must be busy. — no to.
  • ❌ It can be true, but I'm not sure. (possibility now) → ✅ It might/could be true…
  • ❌ They must have dinner now. (in progress) → ✅ They must be having dinner now.
  • ❌ Maybe he must be ill. → ✅ He might be ill. / Maybe he's ill. — don't mix maybe and must.

Check yourself

Type or choose your answers, then check them.

  1. Mia has been running for an hour. She ___ exhausted.

  2. That ___ the right answer — the total is bigger than 100%.

  3. I'm not sure where Leo is. He ___ at the gym.

  4. Which sentence is correct?

  5. I can hear water running. Someone ___ be taking a shower. (almost sure)

You'll need a free account to see your score and the answers.