Non-defining relative clauses and "which" for a whole clause

"My sister, who lives in Hue, is a nurse." "He passed, which surprised everyone." Add extra information with commas.

Lesson 97 Upper-intermediate · B2

In one sentence

A non-defining relative clause adds extra information about a noun, between commas; which can also comment on a whole clause.

Tip: My brother, who lives in Da Nang, is a doctor. — you could remove the clause and the sentence still works.

The form

Defining Non-defining
Commas no yes
Information necessary extra
that possible never
Drop the pronoun possible (object) never
Example The man who called is my boss. Mr Lee, who called, is my boss.
Pronoun For Example
who people Mia, who is a teacher, loves books.
which things The book, which was cheap, is great.
whose possession Leo, whose car broke down, took a taxi.
where / when place / time Hue, where I was born, is beautiful.
which (whole clause) comment on the idea He passed, which surprised us.
preposition + whom / which formal My boss, to whom I wrote, replied.

When to use it

  1. Extra facts about a person or thing with a name — Paris, which is the capital of France, is huge.
  2. A comment on the whole sentence — It rained all day, which was a pity.
  3. Giving quantities (formal) — There were fifty guests, most of whom I knew.
  4. Writing and formal speech — less common in casual talk.

Tip: Never that here, and use commas in writing. If you delete the clause and the meaning is lost or unclear, it's defining — no commas.

Examples with Leo & Mia

  • Mia: My manager, who is very strict, cancelled the meeting.
  • Leo: Really? That's good, which surprises me!
  • Mia: We had pizza at Luigi's, where we first met.
  • Leo: And Luigi, whose pizza is the best in town, sent us a free dessert.

Common mistakes

  • ❌ My mother, that is a teacher, loves books. → ✅ My mother, who is a teacher, loves books.
  • ❌ My car, which I bought it last year, is red. → ✅ My car, which I bought last year, is red. — no extra it.
  • ❌ Mia who is my sister lives in Hanoi. → ✅ Mia*,** who is my sister**,** lives in Hanoi.*
  • ❌ He didn't come, what annoyed me. → ✅ He didn't come, which annoyed me.
  • ❌ My brother, who I love, who lives in Hue… → ✅ My brother, who lives in Hue, is my best friend. — one clause at a time.

Check yourself

Type or choose your answers, then check them.

  1. My laptop, ___ I bought last month, has stopped working.

  2. Leo, ___ brother is a pilot, loves travelling. (possession)

  3. She forgot my birthday, ___ made me sad.

  4. Which sentence is correct?

  5. Last year we visited Hanoi, ___ my parents live. (place)

You'll need a free account to see your score and the answers.