In one sentence
A non-defining relative clause adds extra information about a noun, between commas; which can also comment on a whole clause.
Tip: My brother, who lives in Da Nang, is a doctor. — you could remove the clause and the sentence still works.
The form
| Defining | Non-defining | |
|---|---|---|
| Commas | no | yes |
| Information | necessary | extra |
| that | possible | never |
| Drop the pronoun | possible (object) | never |
| Example | The man who called is my boss. | Mr Lee, who called, is my boss. |
| Pronoun | For | Example |
|---|---|---|
| who | people | Mia, who is a teacher, loves books. |
| which | things | The book, which was cheap, is great. |
| whose | possession | Leo, whose car broke down, took a taxi. |
| where / when | place / time | Hue, where I was born, is beautiful. |
| which (whole clause) | comment on the idea | He passed, which surprised us. |
| preposition + whom / which | formal | My boss, to whom I wrote, replied. |
When to use it
- Extra facts about a person or thing with a name — Paris, which is the capital of France, is huge.
- A comment on the whole sentence — It rained all day, which was a pity.
- Giving quantities (formal) — There were fifty guests, most of whom I knew.
- Writing and formal speech — less common in casual talk.
Tip: Never that here, and use commas in writing. If you delete the clause and the meaning is lost or unclear, it's defining — no commas.
Examples with Leo & Mia
- Mia: My manager, who is very strict, cancelled the meeting.
- Leo: Really? That's good, which surprises me!
- Mia: We had pizza at Luigi's, where we first met.
- Leo: And Luigi, whose pizza is the best in town, sent us a free dessert.
Common mistakes
- ❌ My mother, that is a teacher, loves books. → ✅ My mother, who is a teacher, loves books.
- ❌ My car, which I bought it last year, is red. → ✅ My car, which I bought last year, is red. — no extra it.
- ❌ Mia who is my sister lives in Hanoi. → ✅ Mia*,** who is my sister**,** lives in Hanoi.*
- ❌ He didn't come, what annoyed me. → ✅ He didn't come, which annoyed me.
- ❌ My brother, who I love, who lives in Hue… → ✅ My brother, who lives in Hue, is my best friend. — one clause at a time.